Ultimate Fantasy Baseball Draft Guide For 2025 – Who To Draft & When

Welcome to The Final Fantasy Baseball Draft Information for 2025. It’s my private draft define for who to draft and when on your 12-team fantasy baseball leagues, encapsulating the entire participant rankings we’ve effective tuned throughout the final six months.

On this information, I’ll define who I’m concentrating on in every spherical, which positions I’m specializing in getting early within the draft, and people on which to attend. All my favourite gamers are right here in a single place for every place, with a round-by-round cheat sheet on the finish.

I’ve carried out this draft define for years, and final season I added extra to this already bloated article, turning it into a correct information as a substitute of simply a top level view, and I’ve saved loads of it the identical – consider this yr’s information as extra of this yr’s version than a brand new piece.

Per regular, earlier than we speak in regards to the particular gamers, we actually want to speak about draft philosophy — particularly 12-team customary league draft philosophy, however a lot of this additionally applies to different leagues. I’ve tailored many approaches and refined my technique through the years, and I discovered it’s extremely necessary to stipulate how it’s best to navigate your draft at a macro stage earlier than we decide who ought to be on our radar on the micro stage, spherical by spherical.

For extra sources, I need to direct everybody to our Fantasy Baseball Draft Package For 2025. That is the place you’ll get hyperlinks to all our rankings, analysis articles, sleepers, busts, participant breakdowns, all totally free. For those who take pleasure in this and need to help this little firm I began in 2014, contemplate subscribing to PL Professional, granting entry to our unimaginable Discord, an Public sale Draft Calculator, our 2025 Participant Projections powered by PLV, and our Reside Draft Assistant Software.

We additionally simply launched a Net App model of our Google Sheet Reside Draft Assistant device for PL Professional Members:

Create Draft Assistants for a number of drafts on the identical time
Snake draft, Public sale Draft, and Keeper league performance
Simple to make use of
Mark gamers with tags to make drafting straightforward (Goal, Saves, Injured, Steals, and so forth.)
Lives in browser, no extra going by way of excel spreadsheets
Factors league calculates participant values on your private draft settings
Powered by Pitcher Checklist’s PLV Participant Projections

Just for PL Professional members. Get 15% off PL Professional right this moment with Promo Code DRAFTGUIDE25 – Signal Up Right here.

Draft Methods

There are a lot of tenets of drafting I need to focus on, but when there’s one that you just take house with you it’s this:

You Are Not Drafting A Finest Ball Crew

I’ve hammered this level throughout articles and podcasts for years now and it’s for good purpose. As we put together for drafts, we’re overwhelmed with totally different rankings and projections, from a web site awarding “most correct consultants” which might be decided from their pre-season rankings and the way they performed by way of your entire season (Spoiler alert: These are greatest ball rankings, not draft rankings!) to a group of projections that make you are feeling snug grabbing a pitcher as a result of “he’ll give me a 3.80 ERA” or a hitter in your bench that provides you simply sufficient RBI or Runs to make his spot worthwhile.

That is all a lie.

I’m prepared to guess that you just gained’t be rostering at the very least 30% of the group you drafted by June 1st. Return and take a look at your drafts from earlier seasons and also you’ll shortly see how few picks panned out within the again half of your draft. You need to be drafting in a manner that not solely expects this however plans round it from the beginning.

Consider your self, the astute, sensible, dashing fantasy supervisor. Let’s say it’s the twentieth spherical, and also you selected to draft Eduardo Rodriguez as a result of the projections say he’s destined for a close to 4.00 ERA and 1.25 WHIP this yr. However then his first begin is towards the Dodgers and you may’t begin him then. After which he’s holding a 4.00+ ERA in Might, are you continue to holding him? Is it price it?

The good information for you is that the waiver wire exists. You don’t should maintain rostering Rodriguez and it’s best to have structured your draft with this in thoughts. This brings us to our subsequent level:

Draft Making ready To Use The Waiver Wire

The waiver wire is a magical place. It’s the place seasons are gained, your subsequent favourite participant has a comfortable abode, and it seems like essentially the most superb mall in America the place you may continually buy groceries. I can hear lots of you proper now “However Nick, it’s so arduous to search out somebody good on the wire!” and to all of you, I need to present you a pair of charts I’ve already featured many occasions this low season:

And that’s not even together with this rag-tag crew containing many pitchers you have been capable of seize at particular factors of the season for legit worth:

The entire purpose is to win your league, not go away the draft getting acceptable worth for the spherical you picked them. Seize SPs who’re simply identifiable as early drops who even have a ceiling that’s far above their draft worth. You don’t win leagues being the one who drafted Erick Fedde in 2024, you win them since you took a shot on Reynaldo López as a substitute.

The Frizzle Methodology is the most necessary factor I can educate you: take probabilities, make errors, and get messy. Within the again half of your drafts, don’t go after boring projection gamers so you may present your pals that the “draft tasks me to win our league.” These charts anticipate everybody to have the identical gamers by the top of the yr, and everyone knows that isn’t the case.

Nick, how am I alleged to know which pitcher’s to select up and when? Effectively, don’t fear about that one, simply learn my day by day SP Roundup articles that can come out early within the AM each single day of the season. It’s why I do it and also you will have the ability to get many of those arms — you’ll solely want 2-3 to win your league!

Now that we’ve established that you just need to select up arms off the waiver wire, it’s necessary that you just draft accordingly. What this implies, is it’s a must to set your self up for a sturdy ground, then really feel snug taking probabilities.

The uncooked variety of “foundational” pitchers I need to draft modifications every year primarily based on the pool of gamers and with a hefty quantity of SP depth this season, I discover myself drafting SP like this:

Seize hitters for at the very least the primary 5 rounds. I’ve prolonged this to 9 rounds and made it work.
As soon as pivoting, go arduous into SP. Pivot whenever you really feel assured you’ll get at the very least two of my Prime 27 SPs
Maintain happening The Checklist till you could have 4 SPs…perhaps 5 in the event that they fall.
Go ham as soon as you are feeling from SP 45 by way of SP 64.

After getting these 4-5 arms, take all of the enjoyable picks you want, simply make it possible for we will collectively resolve on them early in April — there’s nothing worse than taking a starter late in your draft and realizing he has poor matchups early that make him sit in your bench. You would possibly as effectively take one thing that can provide you worth in these early weeks.

So take your Gavin Williams, Dustin Might, Walker Buehler, Drew Rasmussen, Jesús Luzardo and so forth. Don’t really feel such as you want a ratio “rock” along with your sixth starter — you have already got 5 others! — and also you’ll have the ability to discover certainly one of them on the wire should you actually need one through the season.

This Is For Hitters, Too

This plan doesn’t apply simply to pitchers. Through the season, the 2 best positions to fill in your day by day lineups are Outfield (particularly in a typical 3 OF league!) and UTIL. Which means as you traverse your draft, plan to depart at the very least one UTIL and one OF spot for the later rounds of the draft. Take a flier on every and plan to look the wire for that one batter who made the modifications you want.

Lastly, I need to point out right here to play to your private energy. For those who don’t have one, now we have all of the articles and AMAs to assist by way of the yr (come hang around once I’m livestreaming day by day!), however should you’re higher at discovering hitting in-season, nice! Draft accordingly to provide your self the flexibility to fill these holes.

Class Targets Are Nice Guides, Not Guidelines

To make sure you’re not getting utterly misplaced inside your draft, I extremely suggest holding tabs on the projected stat totals out of your beginning lineup and drafting gamers to assist fill holes. It’s extremely apparent, however with out a correct goal for every stat, the duty is daunting and nebulous.

As a substitute, check with this desk, which is the eightieth percentile targets for every 5×5 class in 12-teamers, i.e. the season-long stats required in every class to come back in at the very least third place in your 12-teamers. Big shoutout to Jeff Erickson who put collectively each Hitter Targets and Pitcher Targets for 12-teamer NFBC OC leagues in 2023. (Significantly, y’all ought to have a subscription to Rotowire should you don’t already).

Bear in mind, projections are finicky issues and because it’s not a greatest ball league, you’re finish of season stats will likely be shifting all season lengthy. Maintain these targets in thoughts through the draft and through the yr as you make modifications to your group. Assess should you’re falling behind in any of them and make strikes accordingly.

Different Minor Issues To Take into account

I’ll simply bullet level now, and it principally stems from that expectation that you just’re going to be altering your group by way of the season.

Who cares which group is projected to win the season — Yep, I’m saying it once more. You’re not in a greatest ball league!
Drafting is a few ground you’re snug with early, then taking probabilities late — you may change the weak spots on the wire should you fall within the again half of the draft
Know your self as a supervisor — I already talked about this earlier than, however I need to say it once more. Are you higher at discovering hitting on the wire? Are you prepared to make the modifications every day for platoon bats? Will you could have the time to make fixed waiver wire swaps by way of the season? Draft to cowl your weaknesses and open your self as much as reap the benefits of your strengths: For me, that’s loads of hitting early (my weak point) and counting on the waiver wire for SP (my energy, surprising, I do know).
When unsure, draft a better — Many individuals say “I’ll simply get a better on the wire” and I prefer to assume I’m the identical, however man, it’s annoying. Once you’re going by way of your draft and don’t love any choices, drafting a better at all times helps. I’ve referred to as closers “the forex of fantasy baseball” as each group can use yet another man for saves. You’ll at all times enhance by grabbing a better.
Crew building is large, particularly for roto leagues. Look I don’t like punting classes because it places an excessive amount of stress on successful the opposite classes. Go for “common” in saves and steals if you need, and attain on ADP should you want that one man for steals at 2B. Who cares about ADP values, successful your league is manner higher.

Positional Eligibility

Y’all ought to know what league you’re enjoying in. This draft define will converse to Yahoo’s settings as it’s the most lenient of all of them (i.e. the broadest of audiences). Right here’s a fast desk to cowl every league’s eligibility settings:

Don’t know if a participant I’ve talked about is eligible in your CBS or ESPN league? My good good friend Gray Albright over at Razzball went over each multi-positional participant and outlined their video games performed at every place. It rocks.

Alright, I feel that’s sufficient ranting earlier than the draft define. I wanted to let all of that out as, with out the understanding of how I’m enjoying the common season, this draft define doesn’t make sense. You have to be doing each in tandem to win your leagues. You bought this.

…effective. Yet another time

You aren’t drafting a greatest ball group.

Okay okay, let’s really transfer on now.

Who I’m Drafting Spherical By Spherical

Draft Define Primer

H’okay, the actual meat of this text. Let’s go over the small print of those picks and why I’m selecting who I’m:

This define is supposed for a redraft, 12-teamer 5×5 Roto or H2H league with 23 rounds. It nonetheless applies to most variants, however clearly, it’s not a one-size-fits-all.
Typically, the positional eligibility is from Yahoo. Know your league’s settings and regulate accordingly.
I’ve purposefully left some holes as a result of drafts are fluid creatures that want affection and fixed consideration to nail down excellent.

I don’t repeat names for a number of rounds, as a substitute simply itemizing them for the primary spherical I search for them. It makes for a cleaner sheet.

Don’t observe this so rigidly that when Elly De La Cruz falls to the seventh spherical you ignore him, nor do you ignore that you could have to succeed in an additional spherical from these targets at occasions.
Spherical targets are primarily based on Fantasy Professionals’ ADP, which merges NFBC, Yahoo, and CBS information. They’re a tough estimation and will provide you with a basic thought of when you have to be seeking to seize them.
There are particular gamers who’ve spherical labels effectively earlier than or after their ADP. Both I need to attain or I’ve seen them fall persistently and can watch their inventory mid-draft.

These aren’t the solely gamers I’m seeking to draft, however they’re those that I’m hoping fall to the best place.
I can’t record each participant at each place for apparent causes. You need to 100% be studying the participant rating articles from Scott Chu, Rick Graham, and myself that present detailed reasoning for our affection or skepticism. I’m sorry I can’t reply all feedback that ask “Why aren’t you contemplating [Player]?” or “You forgot [This Player]. He wasn’t forgotten, simply not somebody I discovered myself taking both as a result of I preferred others at that spot or thought he was going too early.
I highlighted my favourite gamers for every place in inexperienced inside their tables. Remember this isn’t included within the grasp chart on the backside as it will complicate issues an excessive amount of.
“What’s your ultimate quantity of SPs and Bench bats?” Usually: 10x SP, 2x RP, 1x Hitters in a typical day by day league with 4 bench spots, shifting to 8x SP and 3x Hitters after a number of weeks. Why? Getting PAs every day is extra necessary than an additional begin because the season progresses, however SPs with full-season worth are simpler to determine in April and require aggressive bench stashing.
Take into account multi-positional eligibility on your last hitters. It’s for Mondays and Thursdays when groups have days off — you need as many PAs as attainable and multi-positional gamers can do wonders. Even a 1-for-4 with a Run and RBI can add up a lot throughout 25+ weeks.

Draft Developments I’ve Seen

I’ve carried out a ton of mocks this pre-season, testing methods from totally different positions, and I’m going to usher in extra bullet factors to go over the final strategy I’ve in drafts:

The development you’ll see is that I elect to attend on grabbing beginning pitchers. This isn’t for everybody and I perceive if you wish to be just a little extra aggressive than I’m.

I’m a big believer that you have to be drafting with the mindset of three to 4 SPs that you just belief by way of the yr, then your last 4 SPs are choices that you just’re okay dropping in the event that they don’t pan out.
Additionally, hitting is far extra beneficial within the first two rounds than SP as the worth hole between the highest vs. middling hitters and high vs. middling pitchers is monstrous.

Draft place at all times issues and it’s best to be taught to adapt primarily based in your draft slot. For instance, drafting within the back-half permits for Francisco Lindor or Freddie Freeman, whereas early within the draft suggests extra Ketel Marte with a stud OF within the first. That dramatically shifts your positional focus and who your targets ought to be inside the highest 10 rounds. Have a plan for every place.
Closers are dumb, and I hate them. You’re higher off solidifying your offense than feeling OK with a stat that makes up solely 10% of your week-to-week and isn’t even a assure. Try Alex Quick’s We’ve Drafted Saves Incorrect Once more and also you’ll perceive.
The ultimate eight rounds or so will likely be capturing for upside starters and bats. There are such a lot of to select from. I’ve particular guys I like. You most likely have totally different ones, and that’s cool. Get your guys.

Alright, I feel you perceive the stream. Get tons of offense early, shift a spotlight to SP someplace between rounds 5-9, and discover the stream after spherical 10 on your wants.

Now let’s concentrate on the particular gamers to focus on throughout your drafts by place and later round-by-round.

Why Don’t You Have [Player] Listed?!

I’m addressing this a second time as a result of I’m wagering you skipped loads of this text. That is my private define of gamers who I’m concentrating on. It means there are lots of I ignored as a result of they aren’t a great worth in my private view (I’m not a fan of Gunnar Henderson, for instance) or just isn’t the place I need to goal at the moment (early SP and RP, for instance).

Second Basemen

For detailed evaluation on Second Basemen, try Scott Chu’s Positional Rankings for 2024 Fantasy Baseball.

Third Basemen

For detailed evaluation on Third Basemen, try Scott Chu’s Positional Rankings for 2024 Fantasy Baseball.

Shortstops

For detailed evaluation on Shortstops, try Scott Chu’s Positional Rankings for 2024 Fantasy Baseball.

Outfielders

For detailed evaluation on Outfielders, try Scott Chu’s Positional Rankings for 2024 Fantasy Baseball.

Catchers

For detailed evaluation on Catchers, try Scott Chu’s Positional Rankings for 2024 Fantasy Baseball.

Reduction Pitchers

For detailed evaluation on Reduction Pitchers, try Rick Graham’s Nearer Rankings for 2024 Fantasy Baseball.

Beginning Pitchers

Now for my favourite half – Beginning Pitchers. I’ve shared my ideas aplenty throughout the final six months and with regards to my evaluations vs. the ADP, listed below are the key takeaways:

Seize hitters for at the very least the primary 5 rounds. I’ve prolonged this to 9 rounds and made it work.
As soon as pivoting, go arduous into SP. Pivot whenever you really feel assured you’ll get at the very least two of my Prime 27 SPs
Maintain happening The Checklist till you could have 4 SPs…perhaps 5 in the event that they fall.
Go ham as soon as you are feeling from SP 45 by way of SP 64.

Comply with alongside simply with my My Newest Prime 100 SP Beginning Pitcher Rankings – Up to date March twelfth

Look, if it’s your sport to get SP early, then go forward. Do your factor. That is the way in which I like to recommend doing 12-team drafts that provides you essentially the most worth leaving your draft and opens the door for essentially the most prospects in-season.

I’ve written so many phrases about these pitchers during the last six months and should you’re curious as to why these pitchers have been chosen, learn the Prime 100 SP Rankings above and should you actually desire a novel, learn the 75,000 phrases I wrote protecting the Prime 400 Beginning Pitchers – Up to date February eighth

All Targets Spherical By Spherical Cheat Sheet

I made this useful chart so that you can reference by way of your draft:

And right here is one large desk of all gamers by spherical and place listed.

Bonus For PL+ and PL Professional Members

PL+ and PL Professional members get entry on to the Excel sheet that I will likely be updating shifting ahead given participant accidents and information. You could find it in pinned contained in the #fantasy-help channel.

Get 15% off PL Professional Yearly with promo code DRAFTGUIDE25 – Join right here

Good luck! Right here’s to a enjoyable 2025 season forward.