Ottoneu: Lucas’ Keep or Cut Decisions at C

Assuming every staff in your Ottoneu factors league rosters two catchers, and you might be taking part in in a twelve-team league, the substitute stage factors per sport (P/G) mark for catchers in 2024 was 3.4. Meaning in most leagues, it’s best to be capable of discover a catcher who can match someplace round that mark at any level within the season on the waiver wire. On this instance, we’d set the rostered catcher mark at 24. However that’s not at all times the case. For instance, if solely 5 groups are rostering two catchers (10) whereas everybody else is rostering one (7), we’d lower our variety of rostered catchers from 24 to 17, mentioning the substitute stage mark to three.9 P/G. For the purpose of this text, let’s set it at a tough 3.6 P/G and transfer on. On this article, I’ll listing a number of the catchers I’m rostering and analyze whether or not they need to be saved on my roster.

Gabriel Moreno, CSalary: $5Average Wage: $72024 P/G: 3.97Proj 2025 P/G: 4.84

Moreno is barely 24, going into his age 25 season and hopefully, therapeutic his accidents. He spent numerous time on the IL in 2024. Groin accidents, thigh accidents (adductor), wrist accidents, and again accidents. It was a troublesome yr for the younger catcher. This could increase crimson flags. In case your Moreno wage is creeping above common, spend a bit further time contemplating your preserve/minimize choice. He’s a catcher and catchers get beat up on the reg. You’ll be able to hope he had a rotten luck yr with accidents, that may occur, however you don’t wish to be paying an excessive amount of. However, a wage below the common? His abilities are well worth the threat of one other injury-laden season. Check out how a few of his hitting metrics in comparison with the league common in 2024:

HardHit%: 41.0% vs. 38.7% avg.

BB%: 11.7% vs. 8.2% avg.

Z-Contact%: 89.1% vs. 85.8% avg.

He is an efficient offensive catcher. Is he a great defensive catcher? Effectively, he’s second in Subject Bible’s Stolen Base Runs Saved behind Will Smith amongst catchers with at the least 1000 defensive innings prior to now two years. He’s additionally third in Subject Bible’s model of DRS behind Patrick Bailey and Alejandro Kirk. He’s not nice at catcher framing, however he’s not on the backside of the listing. You might simply argue that Gabriel Moreno is defensively above common and that he shouldn’t have unfavorable efficiency on the place impacting his taking part in time.

Preserve or Reduce?

I’m conserving this model of Moreno. If he had been on my roster for $7+, I’d in all probability find yourself shifting him forwards and backwards between the “Reduce” and “Preserve” sections of the roster organizer all low season lengthy, touchdown on “Reduce” proper at deadline day.

–

Joey Bart, CSalary: $3Average Wage: $42024 P/G: 4.50Proj 2025 P/G: 4.22

Dang, it’s laborious to research Bart. In any season the place he’s performed greater than 50 video games, he hit at the least 10 dwelling runs. This season he hit a career-high 13 dwelling run in a second career-best 282 plate appearances. His closing season slugging mark was .462, one other profession finest. He elevated his zone contact fee and saved his Ok% beneath 26% (nonetheless excessive). He whooped up on the substitute stage 3.6 P/G I set within the intro. But, Steamer has a regression and come-to-earth season on deck for Bart and isn’t anticipating him to return anyplace close to that .462 slugging share (.388 projection) in 2025.

It will be simple to write down that the change of surroundings helped and that that is the true Joey Bart San Francisco had given up on, however that’s not very quantifiable. What’s quantifiable is the excessive BABIP Bart skilled in 2024 (.321 vs. a .291 league avg.) which made all of his anticipated stats (xAVG/xSLG/xwOBA) decrease than his actuals. It’s a chance choose and although he could have been constructing in the direction of a breakout in his age 27 season, it was additionally very probably a blip of a great season with the actual world headed his approach.

Preserve or Reduce?

Reduce. If he had been costing my staff $1 much less, I’d be extra inclined to maintain him.

–

Samuel Basallo, C/1BSalary: $4Average Wage: $42024 P/G: NAProj 2025 P/G: 4.09

Knowledge factors on Basallo make me extra nervous than enthusiastic about rostering a yet-to-debut prospect for $4. His participant web page signifies that he might not be within the majors till 2027! That appears off given his fast-track via the minor league system. Between 2023 and 2024 he touched each stage of A-ball, ending final season in AAA the place he slashed .222/.267/.370. As a 19-year-old at AAA he struck out 31.4% of the time. That’s effective if he can develop on the plate, however that’s numerous improvement that should occur. Now we see why 2027 is the projected debut date. He displayed energy in AA in 2023 when he slugged .465, however that energy was not current on the larger stage. Nonetheless, it’s laborious to not get enthusiastic about his prospect TLDR:

Prospects TLDR: Basallo has Gary Sánchez’s ability set, besides from the left facet of the plate.

Most reviews on Basallo level to the ability potential and ability set as a catcher. However, what is going to the Orioles do if he begins to catch fireplace in AAA? Adley Rutschman can’t catch each sport, however he ought to catch most video games. Regardless of the projected debut date of years from now, Steamer and FanGraphs Depth Charts are projecting over 80 main league plate appearances within the upcoming season. That’s not nothing. Basallo is an thrilling prospect, however I can’t preserve him for the 2025 season at this wage with no clearer timeline and path to taking part in time.

Preserve or Reduce?

Reduce…or commerce. $4 is just too excessive and the ETA is just too far-off.

–

Austin Wells, CSalary: $4Average Wage: $42023 P/G: 3.76Proj 2024 P/G: 4.71

Wells is on the robust facet of a platoon with Jose Trevino. In 2024, his second yr within the massive leagues, he reached a career-high 414 plate appearances. He had a really low BABIP (.261 vs. .291 .avg) and every of his anticipated stats (xAVG/xSLG/xwOBA) had been larger than his actuals. He walked extra typically in his second season and hit 13 dwelling runs, a close to top-10 accumulation amongst certified catchers in 2024.

Whereas Wells has confirmed himself as a serious leaguer, it’s a bit worrisome to see so many catchers within the “Minor Leaguers You Ought to Know” part of the Yankees RosterResource web page. Wells nonetheless has three MiLB Choices left and slashing .236/.327/.434 in opposition to righties because the catcher who is meant to hit righties isn’t thrilling. His general .395 slugging share was below the league common .399, however Steamer’s projection expects him to take a step ahead in 2025 with a .417 slugging projection. The place does that energy add come from? I’m undecided.

Preserve or Reduce?

There’s not sufficient in Wells’ profile to get enthusiastic about at $4. Reduce or commerce.

–

Adley Rutschman, CSalary: $26Average Wage: $242023 P/G: 4.44Proj 2024 P/G: 5.42

There’s little question that Adley had a down yr. Down in wOBA, down in BB%, down in SLG and up in Ok%:

Will he bounce again? I might wager on it. He carried out at 2023’s stage when it comes to wOBA in opposition to lefties and hit them higher than 2023 when it comes to batting common:

Whereas he was productive in opposition to lefties, he nonetheless had a drastic change in his BB% and Ok%. Did the identical occur in opposition to righties?

The adjustments weren’t so drastic in opposition to righties and in a a lot bigger pattern. Nonetheless, there’s a sample. Rutschman caught along with his affected person method to start out at-bats. His 10.3% swing fee on first pitches final season was the bottom amongst hitters with at the least 400 first pitches seen, and since he had displayed that self-discipline in 2023, pitchers took benefit in 2024, throwing extra first-pitch strikes, betting on a take. Adley’s F-Strike% crept up 3.6% from 2023, however his general 59.6% fee wasn’t even within the prime 100 amongst certified hitters. Pitchers nonetheless revered him, particularly as a result of so typically Gunnar Henderson was standing on first base. Adley tied Keibert Ruiz with 197 plate appearances with runners on base amongst catchers with at the least 90 PAs. That ranks tied for seventh.

You might clarify numerous his 2024 declined slash line by his change in plate self-discipline. He swung extra (Swing%), chased extra (O-Swing%), and made much less contact (each Contact% and Z-Contact%), however it’s additionally truthful responsible luck. His .272 BABIP was effectively below the .291 league common in 2024 and he ought to have executed higher in his common, slugging, and wOBA based mostly on the actuals vs. anticipated statistics.

There was one other time once I wrote a few catcher I assumed was unfortunate. One which I advised everybody ought to take it simple on. That he’d be okay. That nobody ought to bail and that he would bounce again. Adley Rutschman going into his age 27 season isn’t Yasmani Grandal beginning out his age 33 season. He’s an accumulator who can get you what you want:

Preserve or Reduce?

Preserve. Duh. The Baltimore Orioles socks on my ft received’t let me minimize. There isn’t any doubt that if I did minimize Adley, he would go for the next wage within the re-draft. I could have him rostered over the common, however that doesn’t hassle me in any respect. Reduce the generational, switch-hitting catcher who constantly hits within the prime half of the order? Nah.

–

Yainer Diaz, C/1BSalary: $8Average Wage: $82023 P/G: 4.92Proj 2024 P/G: 5.10

Diaz completed 2024 with 619 plate appearances break up between catcher, DH, and first base. That alone ought to inform you that his bat is sweet sufficient to remain within the lineup. His very low 3.9% BB% was truly an enchancment over his 2023 2.9% BB%. But, his OBP of .325 was higher than the league common (.312). He completed that by making contact (77.6%) barely greater than the league common (76.8%) and higher but, making contact within the zone 88.7% of the time, additionally higher than the league common (85.8%). However, in 2024 he declined in Barrel% by a big margin and misplaced a number of the ISO he displayed in 2023:

A whole lot of that may be attributed to his gradual begin to the season and energy hunch on the finish of the season. Steamer appears to suppose the ability will bounce again, projecting enhancements in wOBA and slugging whereas accumulating extra dwelling runs, but his batting common and OBP are anticipated to take a step again. In an Ottoneu factors league format, that’s okay. Slugging is vital and a younger catcher with room to develop at a league common wage is an asset.

Preserve or Reduce?

Preserve!